|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
scarynight Newbie Golfer
Posts: 33 Join date: 2009-07-14
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 5:46 pm | |
| | nientsu wrote: |
Then this qn occured to me, what would you do if you played against someone who drives shorter than you, but 150 yards below, always places the ball a few feet from the pin?
I wud gladly give him/her my wallet.
|
Yah... my father does that... Luckily we don't bet... |
|
 | |
mizzy Incredibly Active Golfer


Posts: 2702 Join date: 2009-12-11 Location: golf club graveyard
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 5:48 pm | |
| | eiji wrote: | | mizzy wrote: | From what I have learnt, Luke's swing is more timing based and yet his irons are very accurate. A timing based swing is more erratic when the timing is not spot on.
Timing based is relying on the wrists to return the face to square or something like that. the follow through would need the butt of the shaft to face back up the line.
for amatuers, this is not a good swing to adopt? |
Your swing also timing base and you are playing fine.
|
I'd sure like to play better.. but overhauling/swing change is going to be a biatch... lol |
|
 | |
tronos Super Active Golfer

Posts: 1113 Join date: 2009-06-21
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 5:59 pm | |
| this is my target improvement plan...currently stage 1.
1. putting / chipping = easiest to improve so putting more time in these areas. Also have to most impact in scores
2. Pitching / short irons (below 100m) = relatively easy to improve and get decent % of good shots.
3. Driver = with proper technique and proper fitting..can get 10m improvement = one iron down = automatic improvement in iron proficiency as most people will be better as the irons get shorter. 20+m = 2 iron down..using 8 instead of 6...automatic GIR improvement.
4. mid to long irons = very difficult to master, especially if we are talking approach to green
5. hybrids / woods = good for distance on par 5s but going for green? who can stop a 3 hybrid on the green like YE Yang did to beat Tiger. |
|
 | |
pushslice Caddy


Posts: 5373 Join date: 2009-12-26
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 6:19 pm | |
| Let's see if the stats support the assertion of the "THE IRON TRUTH". 2011 PGA TOUR (186 players) Luke Donald was only middle of the pack in Long Game: Top 150 in Driving Distance Top 60 in Driving Ascuracy Top 40 in GIR. Top 40 in approaches from 200 yrds Top 40 in average distance to pin after "CHEONG" or going for it in 2 (par 5) but check his stats in the Short Game: No 2 in approaches from 50-125yrds No 1 in birdie or better % from < 125 YARDS Top 10 in birdie or better % if Driver hit fairways Top 10 in scrambling Top 5 in Sand Save No 2 in proximity to hole from Sand shot Most Tellingly his Putting Stats No.1 in Strokes Gained Putting No.1 in 3 Putt Avoidance No.1 in Avg Putts per hole No.4 in No. Putts per round I think it's more like "THE WEDGE TRUTH" and "THE PUTTER TRUTH" for him Buy those MPT11! @Mizzy, his iron swing is beautiful but actually not the best (as you had inferred). He's the best wedge player and putter last year. _________________ For Sale: Zen Zam LH British Open 2010 F360 $200 Mizuno MPT11 52/GW DG Spinner $80 Graman Limey 80S Hyb shaft with VDR grip $70
|
|
 | |
tronos Super Active Golfer

Posts: 1113 Join date: 2009-06-21
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 7:54 pm | |
| http://www.pgatour.com/2011/r/12/13/shotlink-luke-donald/index.html
see report..is it coincidence that his GIR %, scoring improved with his improve driving distance and accuracy? his putting and short game has always been good but the his improve driver is what pushed him all the way to the top.
Just show one need a relatively good drive..no need to be tops, just good enough. It makes a whole lot of difference
BTW i also agree...TM driver, Mizuno irons and Odyssey putter is a very good combo (the best in each category..sorry SC fans) |
|
 | |
buzz1211 Junior Golfer


Posts: 143 Join date: 2011-10-08
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 8:14 pm | |
| Played with a retiree once. Par 4. Hits drive - 180m. Pulls out iron - short of green. Third shot - within 4 feet of pin. 1 putt - par. Repeat strategy every par 4 and 5. Long par 3? Lay up. Second shot - next to pin. Par. Nine holes score - 39. Me? Lose 2 balls to undergrowth. Sian |
|
 | |
tronos Super Active Golfer

Posts: 1113 Join date: 2009-06-21
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 8:50 pm | |
| Btw long drive don't need to be being strong. played with medium built slim elderly gentleman (he claims to be almost 60). Ask to be gentle on him, pull out 3 wood claiming driver erratic.... Boom 240m With 3 wood!!!!. did it almost whole game. Use driver once 250m. He claim technique and equipment helps (he using PRGR spoon). Lucky never bet with him. Ended up giving us a few lessons while the flight behind Waited LOL. |
|
 | |
enwee Incredibly Active Golfer


Posts: 2909 Join date: 2011-12-30 Location: Seletar Hills
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 8:54 pm | |
| True, but still u need to hit a decent distance with a driver |
|
 | |
BigblackGoof Senior Golfer


Posts: 372 Join date: 2011-06-05 Location: East
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Wed Mar 21, 2012 9:35 pm | |
| that's about right bro. also because once you start breaking 90, your handicap will allow you to play blue tee or your kakis will force you to play blue tee  [/quote] Alamak, so true bro... betting all from blue tees... |
|
 | |
HyBriD Very Active Golfer


Posts: 732 Join date: 2010-01-27 Age: 49 Location: Metro Manila, Philippines
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 1:16 pm | |
| | eiji wrote: | Whether you hit it long or short. Short game is key to better scores once you can get your drives in play. So driving is important to keep in play, irons/hybrids to advance and a good short game to enjoy low scores
This applies to social golf/weekend golfers
|
Amen Eiji...Amen to your thoughts |
|
 | |
Slicer51 Super Active Golfer


Posts: 2443 Join date: 2010-05-29 Age: 55 Location: Surabaya
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 1:36 pm | |
| | eiji wrote: | Whether you hit it long or short. Short game is key to better scores once you can get your drives in play. So driving is important to keep in play, irons/hybrids to advance and a good short game to enjoy low scores
This applies to social golf/weekend golfers
|
Yes, with this though. Your short games must be getting stronger? My friend |
|
 | |
Derek Super Active Golfer

Posts: 1730 Join date: 2009-10-20 Age: 39
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 2:30 pm | |
| Perhaps instead of looking at the whole things as a "my way of getting to the top is the right way", we should take the different styles of players on tour as inspiration that there is more than 1 way to get to the top, or translated to us, become half-decent players.
Luke Donald's game is built around his short game and his iron game, improving his driving allowed him more opportunities to play to his strengths, but he is definitely a short hitter compared to his peers on tour.
Bubba Watson's game is built on distance and imagination.
Tiger's Game is build on technique and determination
Steve Sticker and Jim Furyk build their games on consistency and accuracy
Just a few examples, but all these guys are among the best in the world (even ranked 200 means that there are only 199 guys above you and about 100 million below you).
Some of us believe the way to improving is distance, some long accuracy, others short accuracy, others scrambling. It is just a matter of where you choose to focus, and perhaps what your physical limitations are. For some, it may be easier to increase distance by 30m for each drive, for others, increasing distance may no longer be a viable option or it may just be easier to work on short game or whatever other area. It is definitely not a one size fits all approach.
At the end of the day, to be a half-decent player, you are going to need to be competent in every aspect of the game, i.e. driving, long approach, short approach, pitching, chipping, scrambling, putting. However, there will always be parts of your game which are relatively stronger than the others, which is part of our individual golfing signature I guess. No real need to impose our method on improvement on others. |
|
 | |
Slicer51 Super Active Golfer


Posts: 2443 Join date: 2010-05-29 Age: 55 Location: Surabaya
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 2:47 pm | |
| Wow .. you are so deep. Well says |
|
 | |
eiji Course Marshal


Posts: 6126 Join date: 2009-08-22 Age: 32 Location: Training
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 2:48 pm | |
| | Slicer51 wrote: | | eiji wrote: | Whether you hit it long or short. Short game is key to better scores once you can get your drives in play. So driving is important to keep in play, irons/hybrids to advance and a good short game to enjoy low scores
This applies to social golf/weekend golfers
|
Yes, with this though. Your short games must be getting stronger? My friend |
i just had 40 putts today, shot 99....how can my short game be strong.
got 6 GIR but only walk away with 1 par from the 6 GIRs today.
3 par 3s, i 1 on, 2 of them 3putt, 1 4putt. _________________ Callaway Razr Fit Xtreme 10.5* Ahina 60 R PRGR EGG Spoon 15* MRC Fubuki Alpha 70S Adams Super Hybrid XTD 19* MRC Fubuki AH R Adams A12 Pro 23* GD Tour AD UT85 R Callaway X Hot Pro 5-PW PX95 5.5 Titleist SM4 50*, 54*, 58* DG Spinner Scotty Studio Select 2012 Golo 33"
|
|
 | |
TourSwing Very Active Golfer


Posts: 993 Join date: 2011-03-05 Age: 34 Location: Dubai
 | Subject: Re: “The Iron Truth” Thu Mar 22, 2012 2:53 pm | |
| | Derek wrote: | Perhaps instead of looking at the whole things as a "my way of getting to the top is the right way", we should take the different styles of players on tour as inspiration that there is more than 1 way to get to the top, or translated to us, become half-decent players.
Luke Donald's game is built around his short game and his iron game, improving his driving allowed him more opportunities to play to his strengths, but he is definitely a short hitter compared to his peers on tour.
Bubba Watson's game is built on distance and imagination.
Tiger's Game is build on technique and determination
Steve Sticker and Jim Furyk build their games on consistency and accuracy
Just a few examples, but all these guys are among the best in the world (even ranked 200 means that there are only 199 guys above you and about 100 million below you).
Some of us believe the way to improving is distance, some long accuracy, others short accuracy, others scrambling. It is just a matter of where you choose to focus, and perhaps what your physical limitations are. For some, it may be easier to increase distance by 30m for each drive, for others, increasing distance may no longer be a viable option or it may just be easier to work on short game or whatever other area. It is definitely not a one size fits all approach.
At the end of the day, to be a half-decent player, you are going to need to be competent in every aspect of the game, i.e. driving, long approach, short approach, pitching, chipping, scrambling, putting. However, there will always be parts of your game which are relatively stronger than the others, which is part of our individual golfing signature I guess. No real need to impose our method on improvement on others. |
y so serious!!!? ...
btw agree with you 100%
Last edited by TourSwing on Thu Mar 22, 2012 3:01 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
 | |
|